Architectural Landmarks in Mahwah, NJ

The Molfetta Team


Mahwah, New Jersey, is a town rich with architectural diversity and historical significance. From stately homes to modern innovations, the structures within this community tell a story of cultural evolution and design excellence. This article explores notable architectural landmarks that make Mahwah, NJ, a unique place to visit and live. Whether you are a resident or considering relocating, understanding these landmarks provides a deeper appreciation of Mahwah's built environment.

Darlington Schoolhouse

The Darlington Schoolhouse, built in 1891, stands as a prime example of Victorian architecture in Mahwah. Originally serving as a school, this stone building features a distinctive clock tower and intricate woodwork that exemplify the design aesthetics of the late 19th century. The building's original purpose was to educate the children of the workers at the nearby Darlington estate. The structure's preservation and adaptive reuse as the New York-New Jersey Trail Conference headquarters highlight the community's commitment to maintaining its historical legacy.

The Hermitage

A National Historic Landmark, The Hermitage is a Gothic Revival home dating back to the mid-19th century. This house,  designed by architect William Ranlett, is notable for its steep gabled roofs and elaborate wooden trim. Originally a modest home built in 1760, it was expanded and renovated in the 1840s into the Gothic Revival style. The Hermitage was once visited by notable figures such as George Washington and James Monroe, adding to its historical significance. The house is surrounded by beautiful gardens and grounds, which were part of the original estate. Today, The Hermitage is a museum offering guided tours, educational programs, and special events, providing insights into the area's rich past and architectural heritage.

Ramapo Reformed Church

Established in 1785, the Ramapo Reformed Church is one of the oldest religious structures in Mahwah. Its classic Colonial architecture, with white clapboard siding and a central bell tower, reflects the simplicity and elegance of early American church design. The church's cemetery, with gravestones dating back to the 18th century, provides a poignant link to the community's early settlers. The church's interior, with its high ceilings and wooden pews, retains much of its original charm. The church continues to serve its congregation and hosts various community events, maintaining its role as a cornerstone of Mahwah's heritage.

Havemeyer House

The Havemeyer House, built in 1872, is a testament to Italianate architecture. Its notable features include a low-pitched roof, tall windows, and decorative brackets under wide eaves. The home, originally owned by sugar magnate Theodore Havemeye, showcases the luxury and attention to detail typical of the era's affluent residences. The house's interior boasts ornate woodwork, high ceilings, and spacious rooms designed for entertaining. Once part of a large farm, the estate's grounds include beautifully landscaped gardens and a carriage house. The Havemeyer House is a private residence but occasionally opens for tours and special events, offering a glimpse into the luxurious lifestyle of the Gilded Age.

The Cragmere Park Historic District

Cragmere Park, developed in the early 20th century, is a residential district known for its diverse architectural styles. The homes here range from Tudor Revival to Colonial Revival, each uniquely contributing to the neighborhood's charm. The area was initially designed as a suburban retreat by New York City businessmen seeking a picturesque and tranquil environment. The streets are lined with mature trees, and the homes are set back on spacious lots, reflecting the early 1900s trend toward planned communities. Many houses feature unique architectural details such as stone facades, leaded glass windows, and intricate woodwork. The Cragmere Park Historic District remains a highly desirable area to live in, with its blend of historical significance and modern amenities.

Skylands Manor

Skylands Manor, located within the New Jersey Botanical Garden, is an excellent example of early 20th-century Tudor Revival architecture. Built in the 1920s by stockbroker Clarence McKenzie Lewis, this estate features steeply pitched roofs, half-timbered facades, and leaded glass windows. The manor was designed by architect John Russell Pope, also known for his work on the Jefferson Memorial in Washington, D.C. The interior of Skylands Manor includes grand halls, wood-paneled rooms, and intricately carved stone fireplaces. The manor is surrounded by meticulously landscaped gardens, including formal terraces, a pergola, and a reflecting pool, providing a picturesque setting that highlights the blend of architecture and nature. Today, Skylands Manor is a popular venue for weddings, events, and tours.

Old Station Museum

The Old Station Museum, housed in a restored 1871 train station, offers a glimpse into Mahwah's transportation history. The building's design, with its gabled roof and wood-paneled exterior, reflects the practical yet aesthetically pleasing aspects of 19th-century train station architecture. The station was originally part of the Erie Railroad and was crucial in developing Mahwah as a commuter town. Inside the museum, visitors can explore exhibits featuring railroad artifacts, historical photographs, and memorabilia, preserving the town's railroading heritage.

Mahwah Museum

The Mahwah Museum, occupying the former Winter's Tavern, represents the adaptive reuse of a historic commercial building. The structure, dating back to the 19th century, features characteristic elements of vernacular architecture, including a simple rectangular form and traditional clapboard siding. The museum serves as a cultural hub, offering exhibitions and programs celebrating local history. Notable exhibits include the Les Paul in Mahwah exhibit, which honors the famous guitarist and inventor who lived there, and the Donald Cooper Model Railroad, a detailed replica of the local rail system. The museum also hosts lectures, workshops, and special events, making it a vibrant part of the community.

Joyce Kilmer House

The Joyce Kilmer House, built in the early 20th century, is a fine example of the American Foursquare style. This architectural style is characterized by its boxy shape, large front porch, and hipped roof. The house is named after the famous poet Joyce Kilmer, known for his poem "Trees," who once resided in Mahwah. The house's interior features original woodwork, spacious rooms, and large windows that provide plenty of natural light. The Joyce Kilmer House is a reminder of Mahwah's literary connections and architectural variety.

Explore Mahwah Today

If you are considering making Mahwah your home, the unique architectural landscape is just one of the many reasons you should explore real estate opportunities here. Contact The Molfetta Team today for expert guidance on finding your perfect home in Mahwah.


We work with the best photographers, home stagers, inspectors, attorneys and other professionals to ensure that the listing and buying process is handled efficiently and with great care. If you're thinking of buying or selling, contact us today!

Contact Us

Follow Us on Instagram