Seller represented by:
Jon Paul Molfetta, Broker Associate with Keller Williams Valley Realty

53 Mayer Dr Suffern, NY 10901
  • For Sale
  • Single Family

53 Mayer Dr Suffern, NY 10901 Get directions

$709,000 $187/Sq. ft.
4 Beds 3 Baths 3,792 Sq. ft. 25,265 Sq. ft. Lot
  • Stylecolonial_revival, ranch_house
  • Age 69 Years
  • MLS# H6069536
  • Listed 1 Month 8 Days Ago


Sprawling ranch gutted and expanded in 2003 and meticulously transformed into this gorgeous custom colonial. Sitting on just over a acre in the heart of one of Montebello s most desirable neighborhoods, be prepared to fall in love. Rich hardwood floors, beautiful crown moldings and warm color palette are an inviting alternative proving to be both classic and timeless. Double doors welcome you to a carefully defined entry foyer that opens to a front to back formal living and dining room area. Complete with wood burning fireplace boasting slate hearth and brick surround, this may be the perfect place to unwind with the fast-approaching colder weather. Just beyond the formal spaces, is the first great room. Impressive tray ceiling and oversized windows set the stage for an elegant gaming room and with direct access to the backyard, it offers a seamless transition for indoor / outdoor entertaining. Custom kitchen boasts rich cherry wood cabinetry, granite countertops and high-end Thermador stainless steel appliances. Complimented by the adjacent eat-in-area with a gorgeous custom cherry wood buffet, hutch and matching center island, it is a classy way to dress up your everyday dining. Ascend a small set of stairs and discover the second great room. A huge space with tray ceiling and large Palladian feature window. A theatre room with surround sound that could easily transform into the play or hobby room of your dreams. Second floor master suite maintains a large den / office area, kingsize bedroom with gas fireplace and tray ceiling, coffee / wine bar, his and her walk-in-closets and an impressive ensuite bath. There are three additional bedrooms and two full baths. Laundry is housed in the basement as is a bonus room that is currently being used as a home gym. Suffern / Montebello offers a highly rated school system and easy NYC commuting options via train or bus.



  • Bedrooms: 4


  • Full Bathrooms: 3

Garage and Parking

  • Number of Garage Spaces: 2

Other Property Info

  • County: Rockland

Nearby Schools

Rating School Grades Distance
5 Montebello Road School K-5 0.8 mi
7 Suffern Middle School 6-8 0.8 mi
8 Suffern Senior High School 9-12 0.9 mi
NA Congregation Mishknois Lavier Private School 10-12 0.9 mi

School data provided by National Center for Education Statistics, Maponics, and GreatSchools. Intended for reference only. GreatSchools Ratings compare a school’s test performance to statewide results. To verify enrollment eligibility, contact the school or district directly.


Property History for 53 Mayer Dr

Property Tax

Property Price

Date Event Price Price / Sq ft Source
2020-09-12 Listed $709,000 $186 OneKeyMLS
2002-09-17 Sold - - Public Record
1985-12-16 Sold - - Public Record
1984-01-31 Sold - - Public Record

The price and tax history data is obtained from public records and/or MLS feeds from local jurisdiction. Contact your REALTOR® directly in order to obtain the most up-to-date information available.